Editor's view - Keeping a high Profile

19 October 2015

It is interesting to see that the arrival of the Early Years Foundation Stage Profile results has been greeted with rather more enthusiasm of late, now that the Baseline has begun for children at the start of Reception.

The Profile arguably gives a more rounded picture of children's development. It also takes place at the end of the EYFS, marking a defined and vital stage of young children's education.

The Baseline, on the other hand, must take place within six weeks of children starting school, possibly the worst time to gain an accurate assessment of their development. Professor Cathy Nutbrown provides a compelling case against the Baseline in her column, opposite.

This is not to say that the Profile is without problems. More children are achieving the 'expected' level of development for their age. But are these expectations the right ones?

There has been much discussion of the continuing gap between girls (74.3 per cent reaching the expected levels) and boys (58.6 per cent). Yet boys and girls develop in different ways and at different rates - is it realistic to expect four-year-old boys, sometimes taught in inappropriate environments, to 'achieve' at the same level? Certainly, adult men still end up in higher positions and with higher earnings later in life.

Register now to continue reading

Thank you for visiting Nursery World and making use of our archive of more than 35,000 expert features, subject guides, case studies and policy updates. Why not register today and enjoy the following great benefits:

What's included