Opinion

Opinion: Editor's view - Scotland's six-point rating scale is anidea England should follow

Once again, Scotland looks set to come up with a system that those south of the border will eye with envy, as the new gradings for care services are unveiled (see news, page 8).

From April, nurseries, childminders and other childcare providers will be given at-a-glance report cards by the Care Commission that will be make it much easier to check the quality and performance of a service. The good idea of the new system is to rate up to five different aspects of a care provider with a mark from 1 for the lowest to 6 for excellent.This will make it simpler for anyone to home in on the part of a service that they are particularly interested in, such as environment or staffing.

England's early years inspection system is struggling with Outstanding, Good, Satisfactory and Unsatisfactory. It sounds like there is a big gap between Outstanding and Good, though in practice the difference may be slight; Satisfactory has taken on connotations of 'not good enough', although that may be far from the truth. One overall rating does not give enough detail, and if you delve further, the inspection is broken down into the five outcomes from Every Child Matters - not such straightforward concepts to get to grips with as the Scottish categories.

Register now to continue reading

Thank you for visiting Nursery World and making use of our archive of more than 35,000 expert features, subject guides, case studies and policy updates. Why not register today and enjoy the following great benefits:

What's included

  • Free access to 4 subscriber-only articles per month

  • Unlimited access to news and opinion

  • Email newsletter providing activity ideas, best practice and breaking news

Register

Already have an account? Sign in here